Tag Archives: AMA

The Need for a Level Playing Field for Physician Pay

Paul M. Fischer

Everyone in medicine knows that some physicians are overpaid for the services they provide and some are underpaid. The list of specialties in each category is no secret, though we don’t talk about it much.  It’s part of the same ethic that teaches us not to criticize another doctor’s care.

But the sad fact is that in medicine, money is tied to prestige, power, public credibility, and medical student interest.  If we don’t deal with this problem, medicine will continue to fall hopelessly into the “haves” and the “have nots,” that is, those who “own” lucrativeCPTcodes and those who don’t. So the question is how did this inequity come to be and how can it be remedied?

History shows that physician pay rarely follows value, but rather aligns with power.  When I was a medical student, heart caths were new and were the domain of invasive radiologists. But it wasn’t long before the cardiology socialites took on the radiologists and successfully claimed heart imaging as their own.  Power and wealth followed.

Continue reading

Advertisements

4 Comments

Filed under RBRVS, RUC

Why Medical Specialists Should Want to End the Reign of the RUC

Paul M. Fischer, MD

The old doctors know.  The practice of medicine has changed in a very basic way over the last 20 years.  Physician relationships have lost their civility and have been replaced by a level of tension that takes the fun out of collegial interactions.  I remember my first year of family medicine as the only doctor in Weeping Water, Nebraska.  My personal medical community had gone from an entire medical school campus with limitless lectures and many physicians to share in “interesting cases” to an occasional phone call with a consultant in Omaha.  These contacts became my primary source for medical education and updates for Weeping Water’s health care.  The phone calls were collegial, respectful, and focused on what was best for my patients.

What happened?

The RUC is the secretive committee of the AMA that has been CMS’s primary source of physician payment data over the past 20 years.  It has elaborately articulated the complexity of medical procedures but ignores and confuses the cognitive work involved in patient care – collapsing it into a few evaluation and management codes. As a result, many medical specialties have found that their financial success is tied primarily to doing things TO patients, rather than caring FOR patients.

Continue reading

13 Comments

Filed under RBRVS, RUC

Facing Uncertainty: Why Primary Care Docs Must Act Now

Brian Klepper

Over the past four months, the germ of a long overdue primary care uprising has sprouted and begun to flower. When David Kibbe and I first tried to think through how to neutralize the RUC’s terrible influence on American health care, we realized the first steps had to be the primary care community’s refusal to continue “enabling” the RUC – we meant this very much in the clinical sense – through its continued participation and complicity. When the game is rigged against you, there is no benefit in staying at the table.

Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under RBRVS, RUC

Who Is On The RUC?

This list comes to us courtesy of the Wall Street Journal, and is remarkable because the AMA previously has been secretive about who serves on the panel that has held such sway with CMS on physician payment.

Click here to download an Excel file with this information.

Leave a comment

Filed under RBRVS, RUC

The Primary Care Revolt

Richard Reece MD

First published 4/17/11 on MedInnovation Blog

An under-the-radar revolution is going on out there. It is a  revolt of primary care physicians against the AMA and CMS.  It is a request for parity with specialists.  It is a movement to replace how primary care practitioners are paid.

Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under RBRVS, RUC